November 14

What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago today?

Independent Chronicle (November 14, 1776).

“Near LIBERTY-STUMP.”

When Robert Hewes and Son placed an advertisement for “CROWN, Hard and Soft Soap, Poland Starch, Hair Powder,” and other items in the November 14, 1776, edition of the Independent Chronicle, they advised prospective customers to find them “Near LIBERTY-STUMP,” the remnants of the former Liberty Tree, in Boston.  One of the elms in a grove near Boston Neck became known as the Liberty Tree after colonizers hung an effigy of Andrew Oliver, the proposed tax collector, in protest of the Stamp Act on August 14, 1765.  Oliver resigned from the position and Parliament repealed the Stamp Act in March 1766.  When news arrived in Boston, colonizers gathered at the elm to celebrate.  They “installed a copper sign designating it the Liberty Tree … and hung up 150 lanterns.”

The Liberty Tree became an important symbol to supporters of the American cause.  It also served as a landmark for advertisers to direct prospective customers to their businesses.  In March 1766, before Boston received news about the repeal of the Stamp Act, Adam Collson advertised fleece wool that he sold “Under the TREE of LIBERTY.”  In 1767, both John Gore, Jr., and John Greenlaw gave directions that featured the Liberty Tree in their advertisements.  Gore continued doing so in 1769 and 1770, emphasizing that he sold “North American Manufactures” rather than goods imported from Britain.  Quite appropriately, he paired the famous landmark with the nonimportation strategy that colonizers first adopted as economic leverage against the Stamp Act and then again against the duties on certain goods imposed by the Townshend Acts.  Even when the nonimportation agreements lapsed after Parliament repealed most of those duties, Gore continued to give his location as “Opposite LIBERTY-TREE” in an advertisement for a “large and general Assortment of English and India Goods.”  Similarly, Rosannah Moore advertised a “general Assortment of Wines, as are commonly imported to America,” that she sold “near LIBERTY TREE” in the spring of 1771.

During the siege of Boston that followed the battles at Lexington and Concord, the British occupied the city.  British soldiers cut down the Liberty Tree and used it for firewood, yet the stump remained and became an important symbol of resistance and resilience.  The tree was gone, but so were the British, who evacuated Boston in March 1776 when they determined that breaking the siege would be too costly.  They learned that lesson at the Battle of Bunker Hill.  Patriots reclaimed the city … and the stump remained.  The British had not removed the entire tree, so the portion that endured took on new significance.  The stump no longer remains today, but the city established Liberty Tree Plaza at its former site in 2018.  In 1776, just months after the British left, Robert Hewes and Son joined other Bostonians in reclaiming the Liberty Stump, foiling the attempts of British soldiers to remove a powerful symbol of revolution.

October 31

What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago today?

Independent Chronicle (October 31, 1776).

“PUFFING, is not his Talent.”

On the last day of October in 1776, John Langdon published an advertisement addressed “TO THE PUBLIC in general; and all his good Friends, in Special,” in which he offered his services as an auctioneer.  He informed readers of the Independent Chronicle that they could find him on Fleet Street in Boston.

In his lively notice, Langdon commented on a common practice in other advertisements: “PUFFING.”  Many advertisers, including other auctioneers, bestowed elaborate praise on themselves and on the goods and services that they sold.  The Oxford English Dictionary notes that “puffery” appeared in print as early as 1731.  It originally meant “grandiloquent or bombastic language.”  Entrepreneurs adopted the practice to market goods as part of the consumer revolution in both Britain and the colonies.  By the time Langdon published his advertisement, “puffery” meant the “action or practice of ‘puffing’ someone or something; extravagant or undeserved praise, esp. for advertising or promotional purposes; writing, etc., intended to have this effect.”  Puffing and puffery had negative connotations since they suggested unwarranted exaggeration and perhaps even deception.

Langdon sought to assure his clients that “PUFFING, is not his talent,” yet he wanted them to know that he would make sincere efforts to “exert himself, and use his utmost Endeavours, to give Satisfaction to his Employers.”  They could depend on his “Fidelity, Assiduity, and Dexterity” when they engaged his services as an auctioneer.  In other words, he was faithful to his clients, seeking the best prices for them rather than for bidders; he gave constant and close attention to his business; and he adroitly applied cleverness and intelligence to running his auctions to achieve the best possible outcomes for his clients.  In a nota bene, he also made clear that “Moderate Commissions, will content him.”  He did not angle to claim a significant share of the proceeds from items his clients put up for sale.  Instead, he set a fair rate his part in successful transactions that resulted in the sale of their merchandise.  No part of his business, then, was over the top.  Rather than “PUFFING” his skills, Langdon wanted prospective customers to associate humble competence with his auctioneering.

October 17

What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago today?

Independent Chronicle (October 17, 1776).

“At the Post-Office may be had, COMMON Sense … on the grand subject of American Independency.”

Thomas Paine’s Common Sense was advertised widely in Pennsylvania, New York, and New England in the winter and spring of 1776, especially as printers in many cities and towns produced local editions.  As summer approached, the number and frequency of advertisements for the popular political pamphlet decreased.  By that time the market had been saturated.  Readers had many opportunities to purchase Common Sense as the arguments presented in the pamphlet helped to convince colonizers to declare independence rather than seek redress of grievances within the British imperial system.  By the time the Continental Congress declared independence on July 2 and approved the Declaration of Independence on July 4, advertisements for Common Sense mostly disappeared.  Only the Freeman’s Journal, published in Portsmouth, New Hampshire, carried advertisements for Common Sense in July 1776.

After several months, however, an advertisement for Common Sense suddenly appeared in the Independent Chronicle, published in Boston, on October 17.  It was the first time that newspaper carried an advertisement for Paine’s pamphlet, though the Boston-Gazette (printed in nearby Watertown) and the New-England Chronicle previously featured advertisements for Common Sense.  Local printers produced two editions to supplement those that came off presses in other towns in New England and beyond.  The new advertisement in the Independent Chronicle did not indicate who sold Common Sense.  It simply announced, “At the Post-Office may be had, COMMON Sense with the whole appendix,” and several other items that Robert Bell, the publisher of the first edition, added to subsequent unauthorized editions.  Bell published, for instance, “a dialogue between the ghost of General Montgomery, just arrived from Elysian fields, and an American delegate in a wood, near Philadelphia,” separately and with Common Sense along with “large additions.”  Other printers added some of those items to local editions of the pamphlet, though Richard Gimbel’s bibliography of Common Sense does not indicate that local editions printed outside Philadelphia included all the material listed in the advertisement in the Independent Chronicle.[1]  Perhaps some copies of one of Bell’s Philadelphia editions made it to the post office in Boston in the fall of 1776.  Even readers who had previously perused Common Sense could have been interested in reading additional content associated with the pamphlet, justifying a newspaper advertisement giving renewed attention to this pamphlet “on the grand subject of American Independency.”

**********

[1] Richard Gimbel, Thomas Paine: A Bibliographical Check List of Common Sense with an Account of Its Publication (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1956), 78-79, 88-91.

October 3

What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago today?

Independent Chronicle (October 3, 1776).

“The Printer is now waiting only for the names of a sufficient number of subscribers.”

In early October 1776, Isaiah Thomas took to the pages of the Independent Chronicle to provide an update about the newspaper he proposed publishing in Salem, Massachusetts.  In a previous notice, dated August 28, he announced that he “intends publishing a NEWS-PAPER, as soon as a sufficient Number of Subscribers appear to support it, which, it is supposed, will be in about four Weeks from the Date hereof.”

More than four weeks passed without Thomas printing and circulating the first issue of the newspaper.  He explained that he was “now waiting only for the names of a sufficient number of subscribers,” suggesting that his previous advertisements had not yielded as much demand as he anticipated.  Ther printer once again appealed to “THOSE Gentlemen and Ladies, who incline to encourage the publishing a News-Paper, in the Town of Salem … to send in their Names” and to do so “with all convenient speed.”  Subscribers could submit their names directly to Thomas “at his printing-office in the main-street” or to his associate, “Mr. M. Williams, Bookseller, in the main-street.”  The printer did not ask for any payment in advance but only upon “delivery of the first number.”  This time around, Thomas did not make any predictions about when subscribers would receive that “first number.”

He did, however, provide an overview of the price, which he had not done in his previous advertisement.  Perhaps he thought more “Gentlemen and Ladies” would subscribe upon learning that that the newspaper cost “Eight Shillings per annum, exclusive of Postage,” with only two shillings due each quarter.  Alternately, Thomas allowed for subscribers “who do not incline to advance any money beforehand” to pay a slightly higher rate of two pence for each weekly issue.  In the end, neither option enticed enough subscribers for Thomas to print the “first number” or any other issue of his proposed newspaper in Salem.  After a couple of years, he returned to Worcester and resumed printing the Massachusetts Spy after leasing that newspaper to other printers during his time in Salem.