What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago this week?
Providence Gazette (February 10, 1776).
“A House of Entertainment in Providence.”
When John Fry relocated from Newport to Providence, he ran an advertisement in the Providence Gazette to “acquaint his Friends, and the Public in general, that he has opened a House of Entertainment … a little below the Great Bridge.” To aid prospective patrons in finding the establishment where he “proposes to victual and lodge Gentlemen and Ladies,” he clarified that they should seek “the House owned by Mr. James Lovett.” In addition to food and rooms available to residents of Providence and travelers to the town, Fry “has likewise good Accommodations for Horses, and will engage to keep them in the best Manner.”
While Fry certainly hoped to attract local patrons to spend some of their leisure time at his “House of Entertainment,” he also depended on the circulation of the Providence Gazette far beyond the town to generate business among travelers. At the time, it was one of only two newspapers printed in Rhode Island … and the Newport Mercury, the other newspaper, experienced disruptions in publication in the early months of 1776. Sometimes Solomon Southwick, the printer, only had enough paper for a half sheet edition of two pages rather than the usual four; other times he missed a week completely. Such had been the case for several newspapers since the war began in April 1775. The Providence Gazette previously had readers in Newport, but it became an even more important vehicle for disseminating news and advertisements when the Newport Mercury experienced disruptions. Fry no doubt intended for “his Friends” in Newport who planned to visit Providence to see his advertisement in the Providence Gazette; he leveraged their familiarity with him when selecting where to eat and sleep when they came to his new town. Yet he also addressed “the Public in general” throughout Rhode Island as well as eastern Connecticut and central and southeastern Massachusetts, knowing that the Providence Gazettecirculated in many towns in the region.
What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago today?
Constitutional Gazette (August 23, 1775).
“The Public will easily perceive the advantage of advertising in the Constitutional Gazette.”
A new newspaper began circulating in New York at the beginning of August 1775. John Anderson commenced publication of the Constitutional Gazette on August 2, judging from the date of the earliest known issue dated August 9. Anderson published the broadsheet newspaper twice a week, on Wednesdays and Sundays. It lasted a little more than a year. Anderson distributed the last known issue on August 28, 1776. As Clarence S. Brigham surmises, “the paper must have been soon discontinued, as the British entered New York in September, 1776.”[1]
On August 23, 1775, Anderson converted the seventh issue from a single leaf folio to a quarto of four pages. At a glance, that would have been the most striking alteration to the format of the newspaper, but it was also the first issue to carry advertisements. They ran on the final page. One, placed by the printer himself, filled nearly an entire column. In it, Anderson hawked pamphlets available at his printing office, including “Defensive War in a Just Cause Sinless,” a sermon by David Jones, “Self-Defensive War Lawful,” a sermon by John Carmichael, and a narrative of “Two Visits Made to some Nations of INDIANS, On the West Side of the River OHIO, In the Years 1772 and 1773,” drawn from Jones’s journal. Another advertisement offered a reward for returning a lost pocketbook. The anonymous advertisement instructed anyone who found the pocketbook to deliver it to the printer. Beekman may have placed it himself or he may have manufactured it to suggest that others had sufficient confidence in the circulation of his newspaper to merit investing in advertising in it.
Another notice from the printer followed the advertisement about the lost pocketbook, this one soliciting more advertisements. Anderson declared that he published advertisement “for half the price charged by others.” In making his case, he insisted that the “Public will easily perceive the advantage of advertising in the Constitutional Gazette, when we positively assure them that near Two Thousand of this Gazette circulated twice a week through this City and its Environs.” Furthermore, “a considerable number are sent to most of the country towns, in, and contiguous to this province.” According to Anderson, the Constitutional Gazette quickly achieved an impressive circulation that rivaled other newspapers. If prospective advertisers wanted to reach readers near and far, Anderson argued, then they should place their notices in his new newspaper.
**********
[1] Clarence S. Brigham, History and Bibliography of American Newspaper, 1690-1820 (Worcester, Massachusetts: American Antiquarian Society, 1947), 618.
What was advertised in a revolutionary American newspaper 250 years ago today?
Pennsylvania Journal (April 26, 1775).
“He still carries on the Cabinet business … no advantages shall be taken of the present times.”
Henry Jacobs had confidence in the circulation of the Pennsylvania Journal when he placed an advertisement in the spring of 1775. Addressing “his friends and the public in general,” he declared that he “still carries on the Cabinet business in all its branches, at Church Hill, in Queen Ann’s county, Maryland.” That small town on the colony’s eastern shore was approximately eighty miles from Philadelphia, the bustling port where William Bradford and Thomas Bradford printed the Pennsylvania Journal, yet Jacobs considered advertising in that newspaper a sound investment. He may not have expected to gain any customers in Philadelphia, but he realized that the Pennsylvania Journal served an extensive readership in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Delaware, and Maryland. That meant that “the public in general” in Queen Anne’s County might see his advertisement as copies of the Pennsylvania Journal circulated there.
Yet some of the language in his advertisement suggests that Jacobs did not yet have friends and customers in Maryland. Near the end of his notice, he stated that he “hopes to establish a useful trade in said place,” indicating that he may have been a newcomer there. Perhaps Jacobs relocated from Philadelphia. When he announced that he “still carries on the Cabinet business … at Church Hill,” the “still” may have referred to pursuing his trade but not the location. Jacobs’s advertisement might have been a moving notice, alerting customers that he left one town and opened a workshop in another. He hoped to maintain at least some of his former clientele. If that was the case, it also helps to explain why he chose to advertise in a newspaper published in Philadelphia rather than the Maryland Gazette printed in Annapolis. Furthermore, he sought an apprentice and a journeyman “of abilities and good recommendation,” possibly seeking staff to assist him at his workshop in a new town.
Like many other colonizers who advertised goods and services, Jacobs expressed gratitude to “his friends and customers, for the favours he has already received.” Doing so signaled to readers not familiar with him or his furniture that he was an established artisan. He underscored his skill and experience when he trumpeted that he “has given due proofs of his workmanship.” Jacobs intended to bolster his reputation, especially when he stated that customers previously placed orders “beyond his expectations.” Such appeals could have resonated with customers in both Philadelphia and Queen Anne’s County. The primary purpose of his advertisement, after all, was not to proclaim “his most humble thanks” but instead to drum up new business. To that end, he asserted that he “hath it now in his power to serve [his customers] better than before,” though he did not explain what he meant when he gave those assurances. If he had been in Church Hill for some time, perhaps he made improvements to his workshop or acquired new tools. If he was new to town, he may have referred to his new workshop. Whatever the case, he promised that “no advantages shall be taken of the present times.” Jacobs likely had not heard about events at Lexington and Concord on April 19 when he composed his advertisement and submitted it to the printing office. The “present times” became more complicated as the imperial crisis became a war.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago today?
South-Carolina and American General Gazette (March 3, 1775).
“PENNSYLVANIA LEDGER … His First Number may be seen at all the Printing Offices in Charlestown.”
When James Humphreys, Jr., launched the Pennsylvania Ledger in 1775, he sought local subscribers by placing the proposals for his “Free & Impartial WEEKLY NEWSPAPER” in other newspapers published in Philadelphia. Given the extended title – Pennsylvania Ledger, Or, the Maryland, Pennsylvania, and New-Jersey Weekly Advertiser (in the proposals) or Pennsylvania Ledger: Or the Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, and New-Jersey Weekly Advertiser (on the masthead) – it made sense to promote the newspaper to prospective subscribers and advertisers in towns in Pennsylvania and neighboring colonies. After all, colonial newspapers served vast regions.
Yet they circulated even more widely than the expansive title of the Pennsylvania Ledger suggested. Realizing that was the case, Humphreys sent the proposals for the Pennsylvania Ledger to R. Wells and Son, the printers of the South-Carolina and American General Gazette, in Charleston. Dated “Philadelphia, January 2, 1775,” the proposals ran in the February 24 and March 3 editions. By that time, Humphreys had already commenced publication of his newspaper. A note at the end of the advertisement acknowledged that was the case: “Since the above PROPOSALS were published, the Encouragement the Printer has met with has enabled him to proceed in the Undertaking. His First Number,” published on January 28, “may be seen at all the Printing Offices in Charlestown, where Subscriptions are received.” Wells and Son acted as local agents for Humphreys, a common practice among eighteenth-century printers who also participated in exchange networks for sharing newspapers and reprinting content.
Another note directed to readers of the South-Carolina and American General Gazette advised, “Those Gentlemen in South-Carolina who shall be pleased to encourage [Humphreys] with their Subscriptions, may be assured that their Papers will be regularly sent them by every Opportunity.” That the January 28 edition was available for inspection at a local printing office by February 24 testified to Humphreys’s commitment to delivering newspapers to distant subscribers in a timely manner. While he certainly welcomed individual subscribers, the printer likely hoped that his newspaper would attract the attention of the proprietors of establishments where merchants and others gathered to do business. Coffeehouses, for instance, often supplied newspapers from near and far for patrons to peruse news about current events and consult the shipping news for updates about commerce in the British Atlantic world. Humphreys had a reasonable expectation that publishing proposals for the Pennsylvania Ledger would yield subscribers in South Carolina.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago today?
Essex Journal (February 15, 1775).
“We have enlarged our Paper to such a Size, that no one of our Customers can find fault.”
An advertisement in the February 15, 1775, edition of the Essex Journal, printed in Newburyport, Massachusetts, revealed important details about its production and circulation. Ezra Lunt and Henry-Walter Tinges, the publishers, inserted an address “To the Public” to celebrate that they recently “enlarged our Paper to such a Size, that no one of our Customers can find fault unless it be that it is too lengthy.” Lunt and Tinges coyly declared that they would “apologize” for the length by “making a collection of the most material pieces contained the Portsmouth, Salem, Boston, Connecticut, Rhode-Island, New York, Philadelphia, Maryland, South Carolina, and Quebec news-papers.” They asserted that they “are now regularly supplied with” newspapers from all those places. Like other colonial printers, Lunt and Tinges participated in exchange networks with their counterparts in other cities and towns. Upon receiving newspapers, they scoured them for content to include in their own publication, usually reprinting articles, editorials, essays, and letters word for word. One header in the February 15 edition, for instance, stated, “From the Massachusetts Spy.” They supplemented news from far and wide with “Original pieces our good Town and Country Correspondents are pleased to favour us with.”
Lunt and Tinges’s also gave details about the circulation of the Essex Journal, both where to subscribe and logistics for delivery. They informed readers that subscriptions “are taken in by Dr. John Wingate, and Mr. Grenough, in Haverhill; Mr. John Pearson, in Kingstown; Col. Samuel Folsom, in Exeter; Mr. Enoch Sawyer, in Hampstead.” That list of local agents resembled the one that appeared in the colophon of each issue of the Massachusetts Spy, printed by Isaiah Thomas in Boston. At the bottom of the last page, readers glimpsed an announcement that “J. Larkin, Chairmaker, and Mr. W. Calder, Painter, in Charlestown; Mr. J. Hiller, Watch maker, in Salem; Mr. B. Emerson, Bookseller, in Newbury-Port; Mr. M. Belcher, in Bridgewater; and [] Dr. Elijah Hewins, in Stoughtonham” collected subscriptions for the Massachusetts Spy. Tinges likely learned about recruiting local agents from Thomas, a founding partner of the Essex Journal. When it came to delivering the newspaper to subscribers, Lunt and Tinges promoted the services of both a post rider whose route included Exeter, New Hampshire, and the carriage that Lunt operated between Newburyport and Boston. This network “facilitate[ed] business between Boston, Salem, and the country” in addition to disseminating newspapers.
Intended to increase the number of subscribers (and, in turn, advertisers), this advertisement in the Essex Journal testified to several business practices followed by printers throughout the colonies. Lunt and Tinges described the various kinds of networks that played a role in gathering subscriptions, collecting news and other content, and delivering newspapers to readers. Each played a role in making information more widely available to the public during the era of the American Revolution.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago this week?
Massachusetts Spy (January 19, 1775).
“No ADVERTISEMENTS … can be inserted for the future without the Cash accompanies them.”
In a notice in the January 19, 1775, edition of the Massachusetts Spy, Isaiah Thomas, the printer, provided several important details about the practices he enacted for publishing his newspaper. He opened by noting that “the Hartford Post will be dispatched every Thursday Morning at nine o’Clock.” In order that that the Massachusetts Spy “may be forwarded by said Post,” Thomas “shall be obliged to put his paper to the press on Thursday Mornings at three o’Clock.” Calling attention to such early mornings not only testified to the industriousness of the printer but also alerted the public that he could publish updates that arrived at his printing office merely hours before he distributed the new issue of his weekly newspaper.
Thomas also advised “[t]hose who incline to ADVERTISE in the MASSACHUSETTS SPY … to send their ADVERTISEMENTS before two o”Clock on Wednesday Afternoons, otherwise they must be omitted until another week.” To convince them to advertise in in his newspaper, he proclaimed that it “has the greatest Circulation of any News-Paper in New-England.” That meant that advertisers were likely to experience the greatest return on their investment by placing notices in the pages of the Massachusetts Spy. Although compositors worked quickly, they did need some time to set type for individual advertisements and lay out all the news, editorials, advertisements, and other content for each issue. While Thomas might welcome “Articles of Intelligence” that arrived very shortly before taking his newspaper to press, he insisted that advertisements required more time to prepare for publication. Advertisers needed to plan accordingly.
In addition, Thomas declared, “No ADVERTISEMENTS, unless from persons with whom the Publisher may have accounts open, can be inserted for the future without the Cash accompanies them.” He also asserted that subscriptions for the newspaper required “one half [of the annual fee] to be paid time of subscribing” and “no Subscriptions can be received without.” Historians of the early American press often make general statements about printers extending generous credit to subscribers, expecting that some would never pay, because they understood that newspaper advertisements were a much more most significant revenue. According to such accounts, printers supposedly insisted on receiving payment for advertisements in advance of publishing them. While that may have been the case in some printing offices, several printers published notices indicating that they departed from such practices. That Thomas put in place such a policy “for the future” suggests that it may have been a new policy or one that he had not previously enforced. Similarly, Thomas joined other printers who extended credit yet also demanded that subscribers submit half of the annual fee in advance, updating the terms that he published in the colophon that appeared in each issue of the Massachusetts Spy.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago today?
Connecticut Journal (January 18, 1775).
“HENRY DAGGETT TAKES this method to acquaint his customers and others …”
The advertisement from the Connecticut Journal that I have selected was published by Henry Daggett. He created it with three different purposes. First, Daggett mentions that he has stopped accepting lines of credit as payments from customers: he “renounced the practice of trusting out his goods; and, for the future, purposes to sell only for pay in hand.” He wanted customers to pay the same day as their purchases. Next, Daggett moves into stating that he has an assortment of goods to sell in his store “on the lowest terms” or for the lowest prices. Finally, Daggett aggressively mentions that anyone who is in debt to him “either by note or book” must settle with him immediately or he will take them to court, what he called “the expence and trouble of the law.”
In addition to figuring out why Daggett placed this advertisement, I wanted to know more about how it was distributed to the public. I read about “Printing Presses and Distribution” on the webpage about “Connecticut’s Newspaper History” created by the Connecticut State Library.” Once newspapers were printed, “[d]istribution of the final product was usually by the carrier, often the printer’s apprentice. Subscribers who had the paper delivered to their homes were charged a fee. … Outside of town, the post rider was the main distributor of newspapers. The post, or mail, came in once a week in the early days. Often the printer was also postmaster and would see that newspapers were carried free of charge from office to office.” I imagine that Henry Daggett got his point across to the public because of wide distribution of newspapers in Connecticut during the era of the American Revolution. They were delivered not only in the town of publication but also to many other towns as well.
**********
ADDITIONAL COMMENTARY: Carl Robert Keyes
When Dominic and I met to discuss this advertisement, I asked him why he chose Henry Daggett’s notice in the Connecticut Journal. He was especially interested in the circulation of newspapers and the advertisements they contained. As Dominic outlines, Daggett had several reasons for running his advertisement. He wanted to know more about how confident Daggett would have been that others, especially prospective customers and former customers who still owed him for previous purchases, would see the advertisement. That gave us a chance to talk about readership and distribution throughout the colonies and then look for secondary sources about newspapers published in Connecticut in the eighteenth century.
This also gave me an opportunity to share with Dominic that the production of newspapers in Connecticut differed from other many other colonies in early 1775. The sites of publication were more centralized in other colonies. For instance, three newspapers were published in South Carolina, all of them in Charleston, and disseminated throughout the colony from there. Similarly, two newspapers were published in Virginia (with a third established only a few weeks after Daggett’s advertisement ran on January 18, 1775). Printers in Williamsburg published those newspapers. In Pennsylvania, three English-language newspapers were published in Philadelphia (with two more established by the end of the month) and two German-language newspapers were published in Germantown. Three newspapers were published in New York, all of them in New York City.
The situation was a little different in most colonies in New England. While the New-Hampshire Gazette, published in Portsmouth, was the only newspaper in that colony, Rhode Island has two newspapers, the Newport Mercury and the Providence Gazette, and Massachusetts had five newspapers printed in Boston as well as Essex Gazette, published in Salem, and the Essex Journal, published in Newburyport. In early 1775, Connecticut was the only colony with newspapers published in four towns: the Connecticut Courant and Hartford Weekly Intelligencer, the Connecticut Gazette (published in New London), the Connecticut Journal and New-Haven Post-Boy, and the Norwich Packet and the Connecticut, Massachusetts, New-Hampshire, and Rhode-Island Weekly Advertiser. As the full title of the Norwich Packet suggests, colonial newspapers circulated widely beyond their sites of publication.
Advertisers in Boston, Charleston, New York, Philadelphia, and Williamsburg could easily visit or send messages to multiple printing offices when they wished for their notices to appear in more than one newspaper. In contrast, advertisers in Connecticut had ready access to one printing office, if they happened to live in one of the four towns with a newspaper, yet had to devote more effort in submitting their notices to other printing offices when they wished to disseminate them in multiple newspapers.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago today?
Connecticut Gazette (August 12, 1774).
“ISAAC DOOLITTLE, of NEW-HAVEN … prepared an Apparatus convenient for BELL-FOUNDING.”
On August 12, 1774, “ISAAC DOOLITTLE, of NEW-HAVEN,” placed an advertisement in the Connecticut Gazette, published in New London, to alert readers that he could cast “any Size Bell commonly us’d in this, or the neighbouring Provinces.” The entrepreneur explained that he had “erected a suitable building, and prepared an Apparatus convenient for BELL-FOUNDING.” Furthermore, he “had good Success in his first Attempt,” prompting him to follow that trade and seek customers. Realizing that the market in and near New Haven would not support his business, he embarked on an advertising campaign in multiple newspapers published in Connecticut. Along with his notice in the Connecticut Gazette, he simultaneously inserted an advertisement in the Connecticut Journal and New-Haven Post-Boy. It featured almost identical copy, though Doolittle did not consider it necessary to advise readers of the newspaper that served his town that he was “of NEW-HAVEN.”
Not surprisingly, he did so once again in his advertisement in the August 16 edition of the Connecticut Courant, directing prospective customers in Hartford and nearby towns to send orders and other correspondence to him in New Haven. He did not, however, run his advertisement in the Norwich Packet, the last of the four newspapers printed in Connecticut at the time. It was also the newest, having commenced publication less than a year earlier. Perhaps that influenced Doolittle’s decision not to invest in advertising in yet another newspaper. He may have been unfamiliar with the Norwich Packet or doubtful that its circulation would justify the cost of advertising. He was not the only advertiser who opted for notices in the Connecticut Courant, the Connecticut Gazette, and the Connecticut Journal, but not the Norwich Packet during that newspaper’s first year. Even one advertiser new to Norwich passed over the Norwich Packet in favor of placing his notice in the well-established Connecticut Gazette, though he may have depended on word-of-mouth to reach prospective customers in his new location. The colophon for the Norwich Packet advised that the printers “thankfully received” both subscriptions and advertisements “for this Paper,” but that was not sufficient to convince some prospective advertisers in other towns to extend their marketing campaigns to include the colony’s newest newspaper.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago today?
South-Carolina and American General Gazette (July 22, 1774).
“Orders for Books, Stationary Wares, Book-binding & Printing Work.”
Like many other printers, Robert Wells, printer of the South-Carolina and American General Gazette used the colophon of his newspaper as an advertisement for that newspaper and a variety of goods and services available at his printing office. His colophon, however, appeared in a different place than most others that ran either at the bottom of the final page or, less often, within the masthead at the top of the first page. Wells placed his colophon at the bottom of the first page, extending across all four columns. He sometimes devoted each of those columns to news, as was the case for the July 22, 1774, edition, yet other times included paid notices on the first page. No matter what other content appeared, readers encountered an advertisement on the front page in the form of the colophon. They did so repeatedly if they perused all four columns before examining the rest of the newspaper.
In that colophon, Wells gave a grand name to the site where he conducted business, calling it the “OLD PRINTING-HOUSE, GREAT STATIONARY and BOOK STORE.” That name testified to his experience as a printer (“OLD”) and the quality and array of merchandise he stocked (“GREAT”). He advised that he received “SUBSCRIPTIONS andADVERTISEMENTS for this Paper, which is circulated through all the SOUTHERN COLONIES, &c.” That included Georgia and North Carolina in addition to South Carolina with “&c.” (et cetera) suggesting Virginia and Maryland as well. The South-Carolina and American Gazette directly competed with the South-Carolina Gazette, printed by Peter Timothy, and the South-Carolina Gazette and Country Journal, printed by Charles Crouch, both published in Charleston. In emphasizing the vast reach of his newspaper’s circulation, Wells sought to encourage advertisers who wished to disseminate information as widely as possible, whether they aimed to sell consumer goods, enslaved people, or real estate, or called on colonizers to settle accounts with businesses or the executors of estates or described enslaved people who had liberated themselves by running away from their enslavers. The printer also accepted “Orders for Books, Stationary Wares, Book-binding & Printing Work,” a variety of goods and services enmeshed within the book trades. “Printing Work” included broadsides, handbills, trade cards, catalogs, and other advertising ephemera for customers to distribute on their own, contributing to the culture of marketing in the colonies and disseminating information in print via means other than newspapers. Wells wished to generate greater demand for printed materials, including advertisements, that would benefit both his customers and his business. In doing so, he devised a colophon that did more than identify the location and printer of the South-Carolina and American General Gazette.
What was advertised in a colonial American newspaper 250 years ago today?
Connecticut Gazette (June 24, 1774).
“Old Books he can metamorphose into new.”
When Nathaniel Patten, “BOOKBINDER and STATIONER, from BOSTON,” set up shop in Norwich, he placed an advertisement in the Connecticut Gazette, published in New London, but curiously not in the Norwich Packet. Perhaps he suspected that advertising in the Connecticut Gazette was the better investment since it had been in circulation for more than a decade while the Norwich Packet commenced publication only nine months earlier. Until that time, the Connecticut Gazette had been the local newspaper for Norwich, though the Connecticut Courant (published in Hartford), the Providence Gazette, and newspapers from Boston and other cities in New England made their way to Norwich, some more consistently than others depending on arrangements that subscribers made with post riders. In New England and beyond, newspapers served colonies and regions rather than just the towns where they were published. The full title of the Norwich Packet and Connecticut, Massachusetts, New-Hampshire, and Rhode Island Weekly Advertiser revealed its aspirations to do so as it built up its circulation. For the moment, however, Patten may have believed that advertising in the Connecticut Gazette would yield more customers.
The bookbinder and stationer made several appeals in hopes of drawing readers to his shop or convincing them to send orders. Like many others in his trade, he also sold books, giving over more than half the space in his advertisement to a list of books and pamphlets he stocked. Those “Books upon the most important Subjects” included “the Hon. John Hancock’s Oration on the 5th of March, 1774” in commemoration of the Boston Massacre. He also listed many kinds of paper and writing equipment, such as “Sealing Wax” and “Brass Ink-Holders,” promising a “variety of other Articles in the Stationery Way.” Patten declared that he had been “regularly bred to the [bookbinding] Business.” In other words, he received formal training as a youth, preparing him to “bind, gild and letter Books in as splendid a Manner as if done in London.” The newcomer from Boston did not merely compare his skills to what was available in that city but instead asserted that the quality of his work was equal to that produced in the metropolis at the center of the empire. To that end, Patten boasted that “Old Books he can metamorphose into new,” pledging that “at least the Difference will not be perceptible to those who do not open them.” He could not reverse wear from years of use or repair other damages to the pages themselves, but he could transform the bindings, the most visible part of any books displayed on shelves or elsewhere. That claim challenged prospective customers to put Patten to the test so they could judge for themselves what the bookbinder was capable of accomplishing. Even if they started with just one volume, satisfied customers likely meant more business over time.
